Our Trainers | Athletic Club and Fitness Center | New Berlin, WI



Personal Trainers are ready to help you reach your fitness goals. Whether you are an elite athlete or someone who is thinking about beginning and exercise program, our trainers are dedicated to making sure you get on the right track.

Princeton Club


Let our educated and motivating trainers take you to the next level with your fitness goals. Our trainers have helped thousands of our members to lose weight, build strength, recover from injury, train for sports, functionally train and more. There are many different options to incorporate training into your fitness routine from personal training to team training to group training. Our Trainers are categorized as Master Trainers, Senior Trainers, and Professional Trainers based on their education, certifications, years of experience training, and years at the Princeton Club.  However, every person’s needs are different so we help you find the best trainer for your goals and also who will fit you best personality and style wise.

Each new member receives 2 complimentary sessions with a Personal Trainer that include a evaluation and goal setting  meeting followed up by a workout with the Trainer specially designed for you.

To find out more about how our Trainers can help you, contact our Personal Training Director Erin Faught at 414-525-2383 or efaught@princetonclub.net.



  • Theresa Sebestyen Master Personal Trainer/ Licensed Physical Therapist

    Theresa is a Licensed Physical Therapist and strength training specialist who enjoys working with clients to design and implement custom exercise programs that merge clients’ physical fitness needs with their medical conditions and restrictions, resulting in effective & safe exercise activities…

  • Melissa Johns Master Personal Trainer

    Melissa’s mission is to help people live balanced and healthy lives that encompass all areas of wellness, for anyone, at any age.  She is very passionate about introducing fitness to newcomers and also helping those who have been in the fitness setting, to push themselves to new limits and progress their abilities…

  • Amy Radtke Master Personal Trainer

    Her love for teaching others came after she went on her journey of making herself and her health a priority in life again.  Many people struggle with balance between work, home and caring for children and then don’t take the time to take care of themselves.  They often start putting their own health last…

  • Matt Wilhelm Master Personal Trainer

    He trained two years for Amateur Powerlifting and has always loved fitness.  Because of his passion for fitness, he changed career paths and became a Certified Personal Trainer through the National Council on Strength and Fitness (NCSF)…

  • Tom Wildt Master Personal Trainer

    Tom has more than 20 years of experience in the fitness field, including training several local and state bodybuilders and is actively involved in the art and science of physical culture and weight reduction through resistance training, cardiovascular development, and nutrition. Tom’s love for optimizing the well-being of clients extends beyond the purely physical to include the mental, emotional and social aspects of harmonious living…

  • Jeremy Petfalski Master Personal Trainer

    As a Personal Trainer, he enjoys working with all types of people and likes to vary his exercises to ensure the workouts stay enjoyable and help people see the best results possible. He works with young kids just getting interested in fitness, athletes looking for more sport specific training, as well as the general population just looking to stay active and healthy…

  • Sarah Kress Master Personal Trainer

    Sarah took her passion for motivating others to pursue healthy lifestyles and channeled it into a career ranging from working in fitness clubs to training clients in specialized training facilities. She loves combining the motivation she possesses, activities she enjoys and the schooling she has completed to create solid programs she can teach to others…

  • Erin Faught Personal Training Director and Master Trainer

    At the club, she enjoys doing sports specific training, marathon and triathlon training, working with people post-rehabilitation, as well as training for general health and fitness.  It is important to Erin to help people find balance in their lives and live a healthy and active lifestyle…



  • Blake Patrick Senior Personal Trainer

    Blake’s focus as a Trainer comes down to ensuring that anyone and everyone succeeds with their own personal fitness. Regardless of circumstances people should be able to find the help they need to do well and make their own progress…



  • Aarika Milykovic Professional Personal Trainer

    Aarika enjoys working with people to help them become more confident with themselves through strength training, and to also help them become more confident on the weight floor by teaching proper technique.  Her main focus is getting others to gain that confidence…

  • Kayla Magerowski Professional Personal Trainer

    As a Personal Trainer, Kayla enjoys showing people how greatly exercise can impact their
    lives in a positive way. She helps her clients find a form of exercise that is not only
    effective, but enjoyable…

  • Sarah Widmer Professional Personal Trainer

    Sarah is committed to providing the highest quality workouts to all ages – those who are new to fitness or who have been in the gym setting for their entire lives. She is determined to create a fun and supportive environment for those around her, always pushing them to be the best they can be…..

  • Mackenzi Hemauer Professional Personal Trainer

    As a Personal Trainer, Mackenzi loves to help people feel more confident in the gym. She creates fun and enjoyable workouts for each and every one of her clients…



  • Jennifer Yourd Running Coach

    Jennifer is a runner with more than 30 years experience training for everything from a 5K to marathon distance.  She uses a personalized approach to coaching that helps people achieve their goals while taking into account their lifestyle, schedule and running history.

  • Jerome Wardlow Basketball Coach

    Jerome Wardlow Sr. has been a Special Education Teacher for 19 years. With his background as an educator at the elementary, middle, and high school levels, this has led to an ability to tier instruction to the needs and development of his students as well as players. He learned that athletes often need scaffolds that allow them to access the next level of their performance just like students do…..




  • I began working with (my trainer) about a year ago and have achieved some incredible goals in my life.  He is an amazing trainer and coach and is very knowledgeable about so many things including anatomy, physiology and other aspects of physical training, diet and exercise that are necessary in being a successful trainer.

    Michael Princeton Club Member
  • Love this place. Have been a member for going on 5 years and have been satisfied with their excellent facilities and service. My kids love the teachers at the kids club - they actually engage in activities with them. My son has been going there since infancy and they were so patient when he was first reluctant to go. Now he runs in! Also love that there's a channel on all machines with TV where you can view your kids...wonderful place!

    Dynae Princeton Club Member
  • I joined about four months ago for two years to start. I had used the facility about three years ago for physical therapy with UW so I knew what to expect. Three times a week I go to swim classes in the early mornings, do my physical therapy in the resistance pool ahead of time and enjoy the whirlpool after my classes. When the weather cools down I will add some walking and perhaps a yoga class to my schedule. I like meeting new friends and knowing that every time I go there will be friendly faces to greet me and EXCELLENT trainers leading my classes. Before I joined I had mentally committed to the membership. Now I am physically committed! Thank you, Princeton Club!

    Rhonda Princeton Club Member
  • It's my therapy place. It takes lots of motivation to get there, but once I'm there, it's so worth it!

    Elena Princeton Club Member
  • I love the different classes and the fact most of them are free. It's nice to have variety with my workouts. I can chose a different class everyday of just work out on my own. I have also made some great friends during class.

    Brittany Princeton Club Member
  • The BEST gym!! Hands down. So many classes, weights, machines, etc. I've been a member since moving to Madison & wouldn't go anywhere else!!

    Cindy Princeton Club Member
  • Clean. Huge. They have it all. If you can't find it here you should stay home. One of the best gyms I've been to.

    Lee Princeton Club Member
  • Beautiful Club. Excellent facility and wonderful, friendly staff.

    Carrie Princeton Club Member